MANILA, Philippines — The Sara Duterte impeachment trial has drawn renewed attention after House impeachment adviser and spokesperson Ace Barbers questioned the effectiveness of witnesses presented by Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team. Barbers said their testimonies raised additional concerns about financial records and allegations involving approximately ₱817.87 million in unexplained wealth.
In remarks reported on November 17, 2026, Barbers criticized the defense’s presentation of evidence before the Senate impeachment court, arguing that several witnesses had failed to provide satisfactory explanations for issues raised by House prosecutors.
He described the situation as an “impeachment sinkhole,” suggesting that the testimonies had created more questions rather than resolved existing concerns.
However, his statements reflect the prosecution’s assessment of the evidence. The Senate impeachment court has not issued a final ruling on the allegations against Duterte.
Barbers Questions Witnesses in Sara Duterte Impeachment Trial
Barbers expressed concern over the testimony of several defense witnesses who appeared during the proceedings.
According to the House prosecution, some witnesses were unable to provide complete explanations regarding property records, financial transactions, and information contained in official documents.
Barbers also questioned the defense’s decision to withdraw certain bank witnesses who had previously been identified as potential sources of information.
Prosecutors argued that testimony from financial institutions could have helped clarify questions about bank accounts and transactions connected to the allegations.
The defense, however, has the right to determine which witnesses to present, subject to the Senate impeachment court’s rules and decisions.
The senator-judges remain responsible for assessing the credibility, relevance, and weight of the evidence presented by both sides.
₱817.87 Million in Alleged Unexplained Wealth
One of the central issues in the impeachment proceedings involves allegations of approximately ₱817.87 million in unexplained wealth.
House prosecutors have questioned whether Duterte’s declared income, properties, business interests, and financial transactions are consistent with information contained in her Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth, commonly known as SALNs.
The prosecution has referred to financial findings presented by forensic accounting expert Alexander Cabrera.
House prosecution spokesperson Zia Alonto Adiong has also questioned whether the defense has sufficiently addressed the documents and financial analysis submitted during the trial.
The disputed matters include property valuations, financial disclosures, and transactions that prosecutors believe require further explanation.
However, the ₱817.87-million figure remains part of the prosecution’s allegations. It has not been established through a final judgment that Duterte unlawfully acquired the amount.
The vice president has denied wrongdoing.
Property Records and Financial Transactions Examined
Several witnesses were questioned about property records associated with Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.
Prosecutors examined information involving property valuations, tax declarations, and other records relevant to the impeachment case.
They argued that some testimony did not fully resolve differences identified in the documents.
The hearings also included questions about a restaurant transaction in Tokyo and purchases of athletic shoes in Kuala Lumpur.
The defense presented witnesses to explain the circumstances surrounding these expenses, including purchases reportedly connected to a youth basketball team.
Some senator-judges questioned whether certain lines of questioning were directly relevant to the allegations.
Senators Pia Cayetano and Robin Padilla raised concerns about how spending associated with young athletes was being discussed during the proceedings.
House prosecutors maintained that they were entitled to examine the transactions because the defense had introduced witnesses to explain them.
The exchanges highlighted disagreements between the prosecution and defense over the relevance of certain financial activities.
Sara Duterte’s Defense Explains Witness Decisions
Duterte’s legal team has defended its approach to presenting evidence.
Defense lawyer Michael Poa previously explained that the team decided not to proceed with several bank representatives because their testimony was considered unnecessary or could be addressed through other evidence.
One of the withdrawn witnesses was an official from the Bank of the Philippine Islands.
According to Poa, the witness had initially been expected to authenticate correspondence involving bank records.
However, the defense later determined that the relevant matter had already been acknowledged during the proceedings.
Poa also indicated that additional witnesses could help address questions raised during the trial.
The defense said it was working to complete its presentation efficiently while ensuring that Duterte had sufficient opportunity to respond to the allegations.
Although prosecutors criticized the withdrawal of witnesses, that decision alone does not establish wrongdoing or determine the outcome of the case.
More Witnesses Expected in Senate Hearings
The Sara Duterte impeachment trial is scheduled to continue with additional defense witnesses on November 19 and 20, 2026.
Among those identified in subpoena requests are individuals with knowledge of anti-money-laundering regulations, investment registration, food product regulation, and government trade promotion activities.
Some of the proposed testimony concerns Cale88 Foods Corporation and its business-related records.
Officials associated with the Department of Trade and Industry, Food and Drug Administration, and Center for International Expositions and Missions have been identified among the prospective witnesses.
Their testimony is expected to address specific matters raised by the defense.
However, the importance of their statements will depend on the evidence actually presented and examined during the hearings.
Poa previously indicated that the defense intended to call approximately eight to ten additional witnesses.
Possible December Verdict Remains Uncertain
House prosecutor and Bicol Saro Party-list Representative Terry Ridon has suggested that the impeachment trial could reach a verdict in December if the remaining proceedings are completed on schedule.
However, no final verdict date has been confirmed.
After the defense completes its presentation, the Senate impeachment court must determine the remaining procedural steps.
These may include the formal submission of evidence, closing arguments, and deliberations by the senator-judges.
The court will determine when the case is ready for a final decision.
Any suggested December timeline should therefore be treated as a projection rather than a confirmed schedule.
Impeachment Proceedings Highlight Public Accountability
The ongoing case has renewed discussions about financial transparency, government accountability, and the constitutional responsibilities of public officials.
Supporters of the prosecution argue that questions involving financial disclosures should be carefully examined to maintain public confidence in government institutions.
The defense, meanwhile, maintains that Duterte is entitled to a fair hearing and the opportunity to challenge the allegations through evidence and legal arguments.
The proceedings also highlight the importance of distinguishing accusations from established findings.
Statements made by either side do not automatically determine the outcome of an impeachment case.
The Senate impeachment court must evaluate the evidence and decide whether the allegations meet the constitutional requirements for conviction.
What Happens Next in the Sara Duterte Impeachment Trial?
Attention will now turn to the remaining defense witnesses and whether their testimony can clarify the financial and documentary issues raised during earlier hearings.
House prosecutors are expected to continue examining the evidence, while Duterte’s legal team will have further opportunities to explain its position.
The outcome remains uncertain.
Barbers’ criticism reflects an ongoing disagreement between the prosecution and defense over the strength and relevance of the testimony presented.
Ultimately, the Senate impeachment court will determine the case based on the evidence, applicable rules, and constitutional standards governing impeachment proceedings.
MA
Facebook
Twitter