OVP Denies Link Between Sara Duterte’s Tree-Planting Campaign and Cale88 BOI Compliance

by Philippine Morning Post
0 comments
Sara Duterte holds a young tree during a planting activity amid questions about Cale88 BOI compliance

Cale88 BOI compliance has come under scrutiny following questions raised during Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial, prompting the Office of the Vice President (OVP) to deny any connection between its Pagbabago: A Million Trees Campaign and the company’s regulatory obligations. The OVP maintained that Duterte’s participation in environmental activities was independent of Cale88 Foods Corporation’s requirement to plant at least 100 forest trees as a Board of Investments (BOI)-registered enterprise.

In a statement released on Saturday, November 21, the OVP described attempts to associate Duterte’s environmental activities with the company’s regulatory obligations as misleading, malicious, and without factual basis.

The statement came a day after House prosecution counsel Atty. Erwin Matib questioned Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) Undersecretary and BOI Managing Head Ceferino Rodolfo about Cale88’s compliance with the agency’s requirement for registered enterprises to plant at least 100 forest trees.

The issue was raised during the 45th day of Duterte’s impeachment trial at the Senate on Friday, November 20.

OVP Says Million-Tree Campaign Is an Independent Initiative

The OVP emphasized that its Pagbabago: A Million Trees Campaign is an independent environmental program supporting the Department of Environment and Natural Resources’ (DENR) efforts to reduce carbon emissions and address climate change.

According to the office, the campaign was launched on March 27, 2023, in partnership with various government agencies and private-sector organizations.

The OVP reported that the initiative has planted 1,386,682 trees nationwide since its launch.

It maintained that Duterte’s participation in the environmental activities should not be associated with Cale88 Foods Corporation’s compliance with BOI requirements.

READ ALSO  DILG Chief Jonvic Remulla to Fly to Portugal to Bring Back Zaldy Co Amid Flood Control Probe

“Any attempt to link the Vice President’s participation in the OVP’s environmental initiatives to Cale88 Foods Corporation’s BOI compliance is misleading, malicious, and has no factual basis,” the OVP said.

The office added that it would continue implementing programs aimed at environmental protection and public service despite the allegations raised during the impeachment proceedings.

Prosecution Questions Cale88’s 100-Tree Requirement

The controversy emerged when Matib presented photographs of Duterte participating in tree-planting activities and asked Rodolfo whether the Vice President’s activities were connected to Cale88’s compliance with the BOI requirement.

Defense counsel Atty. Justin Nicol Gular immediately objected, arguing that the prosecution was making a misleading connection between the photographs and the company’s registration.

Gular maintained that there had been no testimony establishing that Duterte participated in fulfilling Cale88’s tree-planting obligations.

Presiding Officer Senator Francis Escudero sustained the objection and directed the prosecution to move on.

Matib subsequently asked Rodolfo directly whether Cale88 had complied with the tree-planting requirement.

Rodolfo said he would need to review the company’s specific terms and conditions but acknowledged that tree planting was among the requirements imposed by the BOI.

He then read the relevant provision, which requires registered enterprises to plant at least 100 forest trees within one year from their registration date.

The provision also requires companies to submit proof of compliance within the same period. Failure to do so would prevent the enterprise from having its application for government incentives accepted by the BOI.

When asked whether he had personally witnessed Cale88 conducting tree-planting activities, Rodolfo answered that he had not.

READ ALSO  NBI May Probe Alleged Threats Against 2 Former Sara Duterte Staff

He added that he could check whether the company had submitted a notarized statement confirming compliance with the requirement.

His testimony did not establish whether Cale88 had fulfilled or violated the tree-planting obligation.

Cale88’s Business Operations Also Under Scrutiny

Cale88 Foods Corporation has become a subject of scrutiny during the impeachment proceedings because of questions surrounding its business operations, financial transactions, and corporate records.

The company, which is associated with Vice President Sara Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, is registered with the BOI as a banana chips exporter.

Rodolfo testified that Cale88 received its BOI Certificate of Registration on December 9, 2021, allowing it to qualify for certain government incentives as an export-oriented enterprise.

The company’s registration and operations have drawn questions from lawmakers examining its reported financial activities and employment records.

During the November 20 hearing, Rodolfo also confirmed that Cale88’s General Information Sheets filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission showed zero rank-and-file employees in 2024 and two employees in 2025.

However, separate documents submitted to the BOI reportedly listed 201 direct workers in 2024 and 50 in 2025.

The differing figures became another subject of questioning during the proceedings.

The Philippine News Agency also reported that lawmakers raised questions about approximately ₱776 million in foreign remittances received by Cale88 from 2022 to 2025, including around ₱319 million from China.

Some of the transactions were flagged by banks as covered or suspicious transactions due to concerns involving supporting documents and the consistency of the transactions with the company’s financial profile.

These banking flags and financial discrepancies do not, by themselves, establish criminal wrongdoing.

READ ALSO  After Leni Robredo Rules Out 2028 Run, Who Could Lead the Opposition?

BOI Compliance Remains a Separate Question

While the OVP has categorically denied any relationship between its environmental campaign and Cale88’s BOI compliance, the company’s actual fulfillment of the 100-tree requirement remains a separate matter.

Rodolfo’s testimony established that the BOI has a tree-planting requirement for registered enterprises, but he did not personally confirm whether Cale88 had completed the required activity.

The BOI official said he would need to check the company’s compliance records, particularly whether it submitted the required notarized statement.

The distinction is important because the Vice President’s participation in a government environmental campaign does not automatically establish that a private corporation has fulfilled its own regulatory obligations.

Likewise, the prosecution’s questions during the hearing do not establish that the OVP campaign was used to satisfy Cale88’s requirement.

Further clarification from the BOI, including the company’s actual compliance documents, would help establish whether Cale88 fulfilled the obligation within the prescribed period.

For now, the OVP maintains that its Pagbabago: A Million Trees Campaign is an independent environmental initiative, while questions about Cale88’s compliance remain subject to documentary verification.

You may also like