Sara Duterte former staff members are at the center of a possible National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) probe following allegations that two former household employees of Vice President Sara Duterte were threatened and pressured to sign affidavits containing accusations against her. NBI Director Melvin Matibag said the bureau could investigate the incident on its own initiative, even without a formal complaint from the individuals involved.
NBI Director Melvin Matibag said on Thursday, November 19, that the bureau could look into the matter through a motu proprio investigation, even without a formal complaint from the individuals involved.
Matibag said investigators would need to establish the circumstances surrounding the incident and determine whether possible criminal offenses, including kidnapping, coercion, and perjury, were committed.
He also raised questions about the reported retrieval of the two former employees, including the identities of the individuals involved, the police blotter, and the affidavits reportedly executed after the incident.
Duterte camp claims former staff were pressured
The controversy emerged after Duterte’s spokesperson, Atty. Salvador Paolo Panelo Jr., said the two former household staff members had sought assistance after allegedly experiencing threats and pressure while staying in Metro Manila.
According to Panelo, the women were recruited for employment at a resort in Boracay before being brought to Metro Manila. He claimed they later became concerned for their safety and sought help from the Vice President.
Panelo alleged that the two women were being pressured to sign an affidavit containing accusations against Duterte. He said they refused to sign the document because its contents were allegedly untrue.
On November 17, Duterte’s legal team, accompanied by police officers, reportedly assisted in retrieving the two women. They were subsequently brought to a police station, where separate affidavits were reportedly executed and the incident was recorded in a police blotter.
Panelo said the women were not physically detained but allegedly feared leaving their employer’s custody because of threats to their lives.
Employer denies allegations of coercion
The businessman linked to the incident, through his lawyer, Atty. Mark Tolentino, denied claims that he detained the two women or forced them to sign affidavits against the Vice President.
Tolentino said his client did not use threats, intimidation, or coercion against the former employees.
The lawyer maintained that the affidavits were intended to document reported security threats and support a request for government protection for the women and the businessman’s family.
He also disputed the characterization of the incident as an attempt to force the women to make accusations against Duterte.
The conflicting statements have raised questions about what actually happened before the women were brought to the police station.
NBI may examine possible criminal offenses
Matibag’s latest statement signals that the NBI may examine the incident beyond the initial public accusations.
The possible offenses mentioned by the NBI director include kidnapping, coercion, and perjury. However, these remain possible areas of investigation and are not established charges against any individual.
Investigators would need to review the affidavits, police records, communications, and other available evidence before determining whether a criminal offense may have occurred.
The NBI had earlier said it had not received a formal complaint or sufficient supporting evidence regarding the allegations. Matibag’s November 19 statement indicated that the bureau could nevertheless consider taking action on its own initiative.
Duterte camp questions prospects of a fair investigation
Panelo reiterated that the two former employees allegedly refused to sign the disputed affidavit because they did not agree with its contents.
He also said Duterte’s camp did not have a copy of the unsigned document, which was allegedly taken back by the employer.
The spokesperson expressed reservations about filing a criminal complaint, citing concerns about whether the matter would receive a fair investigation under the current administration.
Meanwhile, government authorities have called for the allegations to be properly examined and supported by evidence.
Investigation could clarify conflicting accounts
The NBI’s possible investigation could help establish whether the two former employees were threatened, whether anyone attempted to compel them to sign an affidavit, and whether the incident involved any criminal wrongdoing.
Important questions remain unanswered, including the exact contents of the disputed affidavit, the identities of the individuals allegedly involved in the threats, and the circumstances surrounding the women’s transfer from Boracay to Metro Manila.
As of November 19, the NBI director had expressed the possibility of a motu proprio investigation, but no formal finding of criminal liability had been announced.
The conflicting accounts from Duterte’s camp and the businessman’s legal representative have yet to be independently established through an official investigation.
For now, the case remains an allegation that requires further verification and examination by authorities.
Facebook
Twitter