The Sara Duterte impeachment trial has drawn renewed attention after Mamamayang Liberal Party-list Representative Leila de Lima urged the Vice President to personally attend the Senate proceedings and answer the allegations against her. De Lima questioned the defense team’s reliance on recorded statements from former government officials, saying Duterte should face the senator-judges rather than depend solely on her lawyers to respond to the accusations.
De Lima’s appeal came after Duterte’s defense team presented archival video footage of former Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago, former Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona, and former President Rodrigo Duterte during the Senate impeachment proceedings on Thursday, November 19.
The videos triggered questions from several senator-judges, who challenged their relevance to the current impeachment case and raised concerns about using statements from individuals who could no longer personally appear before the court.
According to De Lima, the defense should prioritize presenting witnesses who can directly answer questions from the senator-judges instead of relying on recorded testimonies from former officials.
She maintained that Sara Duterte herself should face the impeachment proceedings and respond to the accusations rather than depend solely on the presentations of her legal team.
Defense Presents Videos From Corona Impeachment Trial
During the 44th day of Duterte’s impeachment trial, defense lawyer Mark Vinluan played a video of the late Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago during the 2011–2012 impeachment proceedings against then Chief Justice Renato Corona.
In the recording, Santiago criticized the House prosecution for withdrawing five of the eight articles of impeachment originally filed against Corona.
The defense appeared to draw a comparison with Duterte’s case, in which prosecutors withdrew three of the four impeachment articles, leaving the allegation involving unexplained wealth.
The defense also presented footage showing Corona becoming emotional while defending himself during his impeachment proceedings.
Another video featured former President Rodrigo Duterte expressing opposition to a possible impeachment case against then Vice President Leni Robredo.
The presentation appeared intended to establish the defense’s argument concerning the possible political use of impeachment proceedings and information obtained from government institutions.
Senator-Judges Question Relevance of Archival Footage
The presentation drew immediate reactions from members of the Senate impeachment court.
Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo questioned why the court was watching footage from a previous impeachment case, emphasizing that Corona’s proceedings involved different allegations and a different group of senator-judges.
Tulfo also suggested that the court should move on from the old recordings and focus on the current case.
Senator-judge Panfilo Lacson similarly questioned the relevance of Santiago’s statements, noting that her opinion came from her participation in Corona’s impeachment trial more than a decade ago.
Senate President and impeachment court presiding officer Francis Escudero eventually agreed that the court had heard enough of the video and directed the defense to proceed with its presentation.
Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo also questioned the relevance of Corona’s emotional testimony, pointing out that the former chief justice was eventually convicted by the Senate impeachment court in 2012.
Meanwhile, Senator Risa Hontiveros raised concerns about the fairness of presenting statements from Santiago and Corona, who have both passed away, as well as former President Rodrigo Duterte, who is detained by the International Criminal Court.
Hontiveros said the individuals featured in the recordings could not be questioned by the current senator-judges.
House Prosecutors Criticize Defense Strategy
The House prosecution panel also criticized the defense team’s decision to use the archival videos.
Lanao del Sur Representative Zia Alonto Adiong described the presentation as being in bad taste, questioning the appropriateness of using recordings of deceased personalities in the ongoing impeachment proceedings.
Adiong argued that the videos did not directly address the allegations against the Vice President.
Manila Representative Joel Chua also questioned the defense’s approach, saying it had failed to adequately weaken the prosecution’s case despite presenting several witnesses.
House prosecutor and Akbayan Party-list Representative Chel Diokno likewise challenged the relevance of Corona’s statements.
Diokno argued that the former chief justice’s remarks amounted to an appeal to emotion and could not be subjected to cross-examination because Corona had already passed away.
He maintained that the impeachment court should focus on the actual evidence and allegations involving Duterte rather than comparisons with a previous impeachment case.
Defense Raises Concerns Over Possible Political Use of AMLC Information
Despite the objections, defense counsel Mark Vinluan defended the presentation, arguing that impeachment proceedings also have a political dimension and asking the court to give the defense sufficient opportunity to present its arguments.
The defense also questioned anti-money laundering compliance practitioner Rainer Dela Fuente about the possibility of using information from the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) as a political weapon.
Dela Fuente said the possibility existed and cited provisions of the Anti-Money Laundering Act that prohibit the use of AMLC information for political persecution.
The defense raised the issue in connection with financial records involving Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, which have been presented during the impeachment proceedings.
However, the prosecution disputed the relevance of the defense’s line of questioning, maintaining that the current case concerns allegations of unexplained wealth, nondisclosure of assets, and prohibited business participation.
The defense has continued to challenge the prosecution’s interpretation of the financial records and the methodology used to calculate the alleged unexplained wealth.
Santiago’s Family Says Her Words Continue to Live On
The use of Defensor-Santiago’s video also drew a response from her family.
In a statement released following the presentation, the family emphasized that the former senator’s words and contributions to Philippine history remain remembered despite her passing.
The family acknowledged the mixed public reaction to the use of the recording but highlighted the continuing significance of Santiago’s legacy.
Her appearance in the current impeachment proceedings has renewed public attention on her role in the previous trial of Renato Corona.
Sara Duterte’s Personal Appearance Remains a Key Question
De Lima’s renewed appeal highlights one of the central questions surrounding the impeachment proceedings: whether Duterte will personally appear before the Senate impeachment court to address the allegations against her.
The defense has continued presenting witnesses and challenging the prosecution’s evidence, while the House prosecution maintains that the Vice President should answer the financial allegations.
The remaining impeachment charge centers on alleged unexplained wealth and prohibited business interests. Prosecutors have presented financial findings estimating approximately ₱817.87 million in unexplained wealth between 2022 and 2025, an allegation that Duterte’s defense disputes.
Whether Duterte will personally testify remains a matter for the defense and the proceedings before the impeachment court. De Lima’s call, meanwhile, adds to the growing public debate over the defense strategy and the Vice President’s accountability.
As the trial continues, the prosecution and defense are expected to further contest the financial evidence and the arguments surrounding its admissibility and interpretation.
Facebook
Twitter