Adiong Defends Prosecution’s Questions on Sara Duterte’s Tree-Planting Activities, Cale88 Link

by Philippine Morning Post
0 comments
Zia Adiong speaks during a congressional hearing on Sara Duterte's impeachment proceedings.

The Sara Duterte Cale88 tree-planting link became a point of contention in the ongoing impeachment trial after House prosecution spokesperson Zia Adiong defended questions about the Vice President’s environmental activities. The prosecution sought to determine whether her participation in tree-planting initiatives had any connection to Cale88 Foods Corporation’s compliance with a Board of Investments (BOI) requirement.

Adiong’s remarks on Saturday, November 21, came after the Office of the Vice President (OVP) rejected suggestions that Duterte’s environmental activities were connected to the company’s compliance with a tree-planting requirement imposed by the Board of Investments (BOI).

The issue emerged during the November 20 hearing, when private prosecutor Atty. Erwin Matib questioned Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo about Cale88’s BOI registration and its obligations as a registered enterprise.

During the exchange, Matib presented photographs showing Duterte participating in tree-planting activities and asked whether these were related to Cale88’s compliance with the agency’s requirements.

Defense lawyer Atty. Justin Gular objected, arguing that the prosecution was attempting to establish an unsupported connection between the photographs and the company’s business obligations.

Senate President Francis Escudero, who presided over the proceedings, allowed the questioning to continue within certain limits. However, the defense’s objection was sustained when the specific question linking Duterte’s activities to Cale88 was raised.

Adiong says questioning was part of cross-examination

Adiong maintained that the prosecution’s questions were intended to clarify whether Duterte’s tree-planting activities had any connection to Cale88’s obligations under its BOI registration.

He defended the line of questioning as part of the normal process of cross-examination, saying it was reasonable for prosecutors to explore matters they believed were relevant to the impeachment proceedings.

READ ALSO  BREAKING: Salvador Medialdea Falls Ill During Davao Speech, No Official Update on Condition

His response followed the OVP’s criticism of the prosecution’s attempt to associate the Vice President’s environmental activities with a private company’s compliance requirements.

OVP rejects alleged connection to Cale88

The OVP maintained that Duterte’s tree-planting activities were part of its independent environmental initiative, Pagbabago: A Million Trees Campaign.

Launched on March 27, 2023, the campaign aims to support environmental protection, increase tree-growing efforts and contribute to addressing climate change.

In its November 21 statement, the OVP said the initiative was not connected to Cale88 Foods Corporation or the company’s BOI registration requirements.

The office also reported that the campaign had planted 1,386,682 trees nationwide as of its latest announcement.

The OVP rejected the suggestion that the Vice President’s participation in tree-planting activities should be interpreted as an effort to fulfill the company’s obligations.

What the BOI requirement says

The tree-planting issue became relevant to the hearing because of a provision in the BOI’s General Terms and Conditions.

During the proceedings, Rodolfo discussed a requirement for registered enterprises to plant at least 100 forest trees under the agency’s tree-planting program within one year of registration.

The provision also requires companies to submit proof of compliance within the prescribed period.

Rodolfo confirmed the existence of the requirement but did not establish that Duterte’s participation in the photographed activities was connected to Cale88’s compliance.

He also indicated that he had no personal knowledge establishing whether the company’s tree-planting obligation had actually been fulfilled.

Cale88’s business records also questioned

The exchange took place amid broader scrutiny of Cale88 Foods Corporation, a banana chips exporter co-founded by lawyer Manases Carpio, the husband of Vice President Duterte, and Lourdes Lebosada.

READ ALSO  Marcos Says Government Must Fix Processes That Make Life Harder for Filipinos

The company received BOI registration approval on December 9, 2021.

During the impeachment proceedings, lawmakers examined differences between the company’s employee figures submitted to the BOI and those reflected in its Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filings.

Records discussed during the hearing indicated that Cale88 declared zero rank-and-file employees in its 2024 SEC filing and two in its 2025 filing. Meanwhile, figures submitted to the BOI reportedly listed 201 employees in 2024 and 50 in 2025.

Financial transactions also became a subject of questioning.

Reports presented during the proceedings cited approximately ₱776.64 million in bank inflows from 2022 to 2025, compared with around ₱208.49 million in declared sales during the same period.

Rodolfo said he could not explain the difference based on the company’s records submitted to the BOI.

These figures have raised questions during the trial but do not, by themselves, establish wrongdoing by the company or its founders.

Connection remains unestablished

The questioning over Duterte’s tree-planting activities has added another point of contention to the ongoing impeachment proceedings.

While the prosecution sought to examine a possible relationship between the Vice President’s activities and Cale88’s BOI obligations, the testimony presented during the exchange did not establish that the activities were conducted for the company.

The OVP has categorically denied the alleged connection, maintaining that its tree-planting campaign was an independent environmental program.

The issue remains part of the broader examination of Cale88’s business records and compliance with its registration requirements as the impeachment trial continues.

You Might Be Interested In
READ ALSO  Sara Duterte Calls for Accountability and Action Against Corruption

You may also like